Utah Idling limits the 'Rodney Dangerfield' of laws

By Paul Foy

Associated Press

SALT LAKE CITY (AP) -- Jodi Miller likes her coffee as much as anyone, but she admits to feeling guilty idling her car with a half-dozen others at a coffee shack on a residential street corner.

Miller knows Salt Lake City recently passed a law that limits "unnecessary" idling to no more than two minutes. She's pushing the limit at Java Jo's in the Avenues neighborhood.

"I usually turn my car off. I try to remember that but sometimes I just space it," said Miller, waiting for a carhop to deliver coffee. "It's hard at a drive-thru when you have to start, stop, start. When I saw this line, I thought, is it really worth coffee today?"

Miller is at little risk of getting a ticket. About 20 states, 50 cities or towns and 33 counties across the country limit engine idling time with fines and even jail time, the American Transportation Research Institute reports, but actual enforcement is spotty or non-existent with officials proclaiming they emphasize public education over ticketing.

"It's pretty difficult to get a fine when you can accumulate three warnings before a fine," said Art Raymond, a spokesman for Salt Lake City Mayor Ralph Becker.

Joining the idling action, Utah Gov. Gary Herbert signed an executive order May 31 to limit idling in the state's fleet of 7,300 vehicles to no more than 30 seconds -- part of a strategy to avoid federal Clean Air Act violation sanctions.

Yet it amounts to little more than a "please and thank you" edict. Herbert left enforcement to individual agencies. He says he's doing everything he can to get organizations and people to voluntarily reduce emissions.

Other officials say it's almost impossible to catch idling violators in the act.

"The problem with idling at a lot of places is it's here today, gone tomorrow," said Greg Thomas, a supervisor at Denver's Department of Environmental Health. Checking his records, Thomas said nobody has been cited in Denver for idling for at least the past five years.

That leaves environmental groups complaining that idling restrictions are the Rodney Dangerfield of state and local laws -- they don't get much respect.

"Why isn't this the law of the land? It's such a no-brainer," said Diane Bailey, a senior scientist for the Natural Resources Defense Council in San Francisco. "Idling remains a pervasive problem, and whether there's a law on the books or not doesn't seem to matter."

Exhaust gases are toxic and believed to be the cause for soaring urban asthma rates, especially in children. Advocates for cracking down don't argue that less idling cleans up a region's air, with so many other sources of pollution at play, but it can reduce concentrated pockets of air pollution in front of schools and other places where motorists often linger.

New York City completed a two-week crackdown on idling near schools in May. Mayor Michael Bloomberg got tough after a brush with violations himself -- he has apologized for letting his SUVs idle for as long as an hour outside events.

So how many tickets did New York City issue during the crackdown?

"This is not just about enforcement," said Chris Gilbride, a spokesman for the New York City Department of Environmental Protection. "It's about changing people's behavior. It's like getting people to wear seat belts. There isn't a bunch of environmental cops on the street."

The city issued a handful of $50 idling tickets during the crackdown, he said.

Aspen, Colo., limits idling to five minutes punishable by fines of up to $1,000 or a year behind bars.

"I'm not aware of anyone going to jail," Aspen police Sgt. Robert Fabrocini said. "If there's a truck idling, we'll track down the owner and educate first. A lot of people honestly don't know about the anti-idling law when they come to town."

Meanwhile, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, which is pressuring Utah to clean up its air, lauded Herbert's move to cut idling in the state fleet.

"It raises awareness and sets an example," EPA spokesman Richard Mylott said. "Regional air quality planning is about the cumulative impact of a lot of measures, and this is a good step. Reducing vehicle idling reduces exposure to carbon monoxide and particle pollution as well as air toxins like benzene and formaldehyde. It also saves money and fuel."

Saving money is the ticket for Salt Lake City-based long-haul trucking firm C.R. England, which has been using auto shut-off devices after five minutes of truck idling for about a dozen years.

"You burn close to a gallon an hour idling," said C. Allen Nielsen, the company's fuel director. "For us, burning less fuel saves money, but it also keeps the air clean."

The trucking company also outfits trucks with separate heaters for crews resting overnight in cabs, and speed governors that limit a truck to 65 mph. Through these and other measures C.R. England says it saves about 627,000 gallons of fuel every month.

At Java Jo's in Salt Lake City, fumes are everywhere, wafting into open apartment windows just yards away. The coffee shop's owners argue idling is from a constant turnover of cars, not the same cars, so no violations are occurring. They don't want to discuss it further, however, and order an Associated Press writer off their property.

Published: Wed, Jun 13, 2012