by Tom Kirvan
In many respects, she has served as the principal voice for the court and, at times, its first line of defense on occasional controversy.
In the words of her former boss, Carl Gromek, retired chief of staff for the state Supreme Court, “She is the total package.”
He adds, “With her intelligence, legal background, writing ability, and good sense, Marcia was able to simplify and explain legal issues and decisions to any audience. She was a trusted adviser to the judiciary when it came to questions and challenges regarding its actions.”
But come the afternoon of Friday, Feb. 21, McBrien will begin charting an as yet undetermined career course, retiring from the communications post that she has so deftly handled since August 2001.
McBrien, a former litigator with Miller Canfield in Detroit, announced her plans on Feb. 5 in typical low-key fashion, tacking on a brief paragraph at the end of an e-mail containing a news release she distributed to members of the print and broadcast media. In short, she said, “After a very happy 12 years with the Court, I am moving on. While I’ve loved working with my colleagues here and with all of you, I am confident that my decision is the right one. This was not an easy decision; I’ve gotten to know many of you personally, probably the most rewarding part of this job. Please know how much I’ve valued and enjoyed working with you.”
When asked to elaborate, McBrien said she intends to take some time off to plan her next career move, although she ruled out a return to private law practice. Gromek, among others, believes she will have her choice of plum jobs.
“Marcia is respected and trusted by all who have worked with her and will be missed both personally and professionally,” said Gromek, who also served as State Court Administrator for the more than 240 trial courts in Michigan. “I’m just glad that I retired before she left.”
Maura Corrigan, director of the Michigan Department of Human Services, was chief justice of the Supreme Court when McBrien was hired in 2001 and remembers well how she handled an early challenge.
“Just a few weeks after she was hired, 9/11 happened,” recalled Corrigan, who served on the Supreme Court from 1998 to 2011. “It truly was a baptism by fire for Marcia during that horrible episode in our country’s history. She ... proved herself to be one of the most talented journalists and attorneys I’ve ever known. She is incredibly bright, and can draw on her knowledge of literature and poetry to make a point like few others can. It really was my good fortune to know and work with someone who has that kind of skill set and ... temperament.”
A graduate of the University of Notre Dame, McBrien earned her bachelor’s degree in English and planned to pursue a Ph.D. at the University of Michigan after two years of graduate school at Notre Dame.
And in a hurry, as the next Law School Admission Test (LSAT) was just four days away, leaving McBrien little time to prepare for the challenging half-day examination. Not surprisingly, McBrien did well, earning admission to U-M Law School, almost coinciding with word of acceptance into the doctoral program.
“In all honesty, I’d almost forgotten that I had applied for the Ph.D. program,” McBrien said with a chuckle. “By then, I was completely focused on getting into law school.”
Once enrolled, McBrien found that her law studies “demanded discipline and precision,” forcing her to engage a “part of my brain that I had not used before.” In retrospect, she might have Lee Bollinger to partially thank for that. The former president of U of M, now head of Columbia University, was McBrien’s professor for contracts. Bollinger, who was later dean of U-M Law School, taught constitutional law and is a prominent authority on First Amendment issues, which he has argued before the U.S. Supreme Court.
“He was an amazing professor and obviously has a brilliant legal mind,” she said.
McBrien also credits U-M law professor Christina Whitman with playing “an enormous role” in her legal education. Whitman’s gentle yet intellectually rigorous style “forced me to use brain cells I didn’t know I had” in constitutional and other law.
“She made me a better writer. She would challenge me to be clearer, to focus more acutely, to pare away whatever was unneeded. I am greatly in her debt.”
Upon graduation from law school in 1987, McBrien went to work for Miller Canfield in its litigation department. Her first jury trial was in front of U.S. District Judge Robert DeMascio, a former assistant U.S. Attorney who had a no-nonsense reputation.
“I lost 7 pounds the week before the trial because I was so nervous,” McBrien said of the case that involved a dispute between a major hotel chain and a contractor at Metro Airport. “I was scared out of my mind as I began my opening statement to the jury, but I gained confidence as the trial proceeded.”
Afterward, McBrien received high marks from Judge DeMascio, which resulted in the jury awarding the plaintiff a fraction of what he was seeking in damages.
McBrien spent much of the next few years working on a slew of asbestos cases involving a Miller Canfield client.
“Believe me when I say that after you’ve taken one of those depositions, you’ve heard them all,” she said with a smile. “I was ready to do something different and submitted a resume to work for Michigan Lawyers Weekly.”
Six months later she got a call from the new editor, inviting her to come to work.
“I absolutely loved working there, enjoying the opportunity to write on a variety of interesting legal topics and people,” McBrien said of her six-year stay with the paper. “There were a lot of late nights, but I really enjoyed the challenge of writing stories under deadline pressure.”
––––––––––––––––––––
Subscribe to the Legal News!
https://legalnews.com/Home/Subscription
Full access to public notices, articles, columns, archives, statistics, calendar and more
Day Pass Only $4.95!
One-County $80/year
Three-County & Full Pass also available