County Files Petition to Intervene on Silver Maple

By Greg Chandler
Zeeland Record


Ottawa County has filed a petition to ­intervene on the proposed Silver Maple solar project in Zeeland and Jamestown townships before the Michigan Public Service Commission.

County corporate counsel Doug Van Essen filed the petition with the MPSC last Friday, three days after commissioners voted 10-1 to authorize County Administrator Patrick Waterman to file a petition to intervene on behalf of the county.

“Ottawa is statutorily authorized to assist in farmland preservation and in housing ­development, among other activities that could be directly impacted by the proposed facility,” the county’s petition reads. 

“Ottawa's unique perspective, concerns and expertise are not adequately represented by any of the parties and will assist the Commission in examining the criteria outlined” in state law assessing public benefits that include “advancing and resolving environmental considerations … assessing whether the Project causes unreasonable diminution of farmland … and evaluating the Project's potential threats to health and safety,” the petition goes on to say.

The county needed to file the petition by Nov. 12. A pre-hearing on RWE’s application for Silver Maple is scheduled for Nov. 19 before an administrative law judge.

Both Zeeland and Jamestown township boards had asked the county to enter into the Silver Maple case as an intervenor ­objecting to the proposed 200-megawatt, $330 million project that’s proposed on more than 1,900 acres of farmland in the two townships. 

The ability for the county to enter the case was made possible by a Michigan Court of Appeals ruling in May where justices ruled that all governmental units where an energy facility is proposed, ­including counties, may seek status as an intervenor before the MPSC. 

“This is going to affect our community, it’s going to affect our roadways, our waterways, and it certainly will affect our residents. So I think we should absolutely intervene,” Commissioner Jordan Jorritsma of Park Township said of the Silver Maple project at the Oct. 27 board meeting where commissioners approved moving ahead with the petition to intervene.

In addition to authorizing Waterman to file the petition with the MPSC, the board also authorized the administrator to coordinate the county’s position and testimony, and identify and retain legal counsel for its role as an intervenor in the Silver Maple case. 
Commissioners also authorized the use of $50,000 in funding provided by RWE – a required payment under Public Act 233 – to cover any legal or other costs associated with participating in the case.

“That gets us a seat at the table. It doesn’t say we’re for solar or against solar,” Commissioner Jim Barry of Park Township said. “It’s just a project of this kind of scale is coming into the county, and we just want to make sure that county concerns and ­issues are addressed, and that we have a seat at the table for the discussion as this goes forward.”

Several commissioners spoke out against Public Act 233, a 2023 law that regulates renewable energy projects in the state, and gives the ability for developers to bypass local governmental units and apply directly to the state for approval of large-scale solar, wind and battery energy storage projects.

“Some bureaucrats in Lansing sat in a ­cubicle and wrote this up, and basically axed our voice out of the conversation,” Commissioner Jacob Bonnema of Zeeland said. “That needs to stop. We need to stand together.”

“I really hope that we as a board can be a constructive partner at the table, that we’re not there to do anything else but … to help craft policy that works for everybody involved,” Bonnema added.

Commissioner John Teeples of Georgetown Township called PA 233 “shameful for the state of Michigan.”

“We, as a county, it seems to be, can play a role in trying to bring our communities together and say, look, if we’re going to have to deal with these issues (tied to PA 233), let’s have something that we can all get around … farmland preservation, stormwater, infrastructure,” Teeples said. “Let’s bring it together as a county.”

Commissioner Doug Zylstra of Holland was the lone no vote.

“I continue to see this matter as … ­individual landowners and farmers exercising their private property rights,” Zylstra said.

As part of the motion to retain legal counsel, commissioners adopted an amendment by Commissioner Sylvia Rhodea of Allendale Township “that the county’s substantive policy position shall remain subject to the direction and ­approval of the Board of Commissioners.”

Rhodea’s amendment also stated “any proposed host community agreement or ­related settlement, including any commitment to support the project, withdraw ­intervention, waive appeal rights or otherwise limit the county’s legal rights shall ­require the express approval of the Board of Commissioners before the county ­becomes bound.”

Van Essen told commissioners at the Oct. 27 meeting that he did not expect any challenges to the county entering the Silver Maple case. He recently sat in on a hearing on another RWE project in Lenawee County – the administrative law judge in that case is the same one that is presiding over Silver Maple – and the judge allowed the county to enter as an intervenor.

“He found Lenawee County was a county. It’s all he needed, and (they) wanted to be involved,” Van Essen said. “He didn’t even drop to their permissive ­intervention issues. He said ‘you’re in.’ And so, he’ll do that here as well.”

Van Essen went on to say that the county’s position and testimony on Silver Maple would probably have to be presented by mid-January.

Zeeland Township Supervisor Kerri Bosma wrote in a text message to The Zeeland Record that she was “thankful” to the board for “recognizing the importance of having the county at the table as an intervenor” on Silver Maple.

“I’ve had the opportunity to have several conversations with county officials and ­administration about what our township is facing, and I’m grateful we can work ­together,” Bosma wrote. “I recognize the county will be looking at this through the lens of its countywide interests, which is important because there are areas of concern beyond our township’s jurisdiction. Having the county involved gives another voice to help protect the interests of Ottawa County and its residents.”


––––––––––––––––––––
Subscribe to the Legal News!
https://legalnews.com/Home/Subscription
Full access to public notices, articles, columns, archives, statistics, calendar and more
Day Pass Only $4.95!
One-County $80/year
Three-County & Full Pass also available