Zeeland Record
A federal judge in Grand Rapids has ordered that a lawsuit filed by Zeeland Township against the developer of the Silver Maple solar project be remanded from federal court back to Ottawa County.
In a nine-page opinion issued Nov. 10, U.S. District Judge Paul Maloney granted a motion by the township to remand its lawsuit against RWE Solar Development LLC to Ottawa County Circuit Court. The lawsuit, filed July 7, challenges the constitutionality of Public Act 233, the Michigan law that establishes a siting process for utility-scale solar, wind and energy storage facilities in the state.
“First, any decision by this court regarding whether Public Act 233 violates the Michigan Constitution is not binding on Michigan courts, so exercising jurisdiction here would not be useful,” Maloney wrote in his opinion. “Second, exercising jurisdiction over this action would not be fair. The court will not cross the line into state sovereignty by exercising jurisdiction over a case that involves purely questions of state law, especially when mainly of those questions require interpreting a state constitution.”
RWE had moved the case from the local court to U.S. District Court in Grand Rapids in early August under the argument of diversity jurisdiction, citing the township is a Michigan municipality while the project developers are incorporated in Delaware and RWE’s global headquarters are in Germany.
Maloney agreed with RWE that the federal court did indeed have diversity jurisdiction over the case, but other factors led the court to decline to exercise that jurisdiction.
First, Maloney wrote, “It is well-settled law that ‘a federal court’s interpretation of state law is not binding on that State’s courts.’ Thus, this court’s decision would not settle the ultimate controversy, which is whether Public Act 233 violates the Michigan Constitution.”
Next, the judge wrote that the state court is better equipped to analyze “novel questions of state law” and that “whether the issue in the federal action implicates important state policies and is, thus, more appropriately considered in state court.”
“This action is about the relationship between the state and local governments and contains only questions of state law. This action is certainly more appropriately considered in state court,” Maloney wrote.
Township Supervisor Kerri Bosma praised the ruling, saying the case belongs in “our local courts.”
“This is a Michigan issue, involving Michigan communities and local government authority, and we believe it should be heard and decided here at home,” Bosma wrote in a text message to The Zeeland Record.
RWE spokeswoman Amy LeFebre issued the following statement in an email to The Zeeland Record: “We respect the court's decision. RWE remains committed to responsible solar development in Michigan, and we are reviewing the ruling with legal counsel to determine next steps.”
No new dates for hearing the lawsuit in Ottawa County have been set, according to county court records.
RWE initially applied for approval of Silver Maple, a proposed 200-megawatt project planned for more than 1,900 acres of farmland in Zeeland and Jamestown townships, with the Michigan Public Service Commission in April. After a Michigan Court of Appeals ruling allowed Ottawa County to enter into the case as an intervenor, the company suspended its application, then refiled in September.
A pre-hearing on RWE’s new application for Silver Maple was scheduled to take place at 9 a.m. today before Administrative Law Judge James Varchetti. The hearing was to be held via video/teleconference, according to an MPSC notice.
It’s expected that Varchetti will consider whether allowing the county to enter the case as an intervenor. The pre-hearing is also expected to reset the timetable for testimony, both in favor and opposed to Silver Maple, as well as when the three-member MPSC will ultimately decide the fate of the project.
Meanwhile, an informational meeting to update the community on the status of the Silver Maple project and the township’s efforts to block it will take place tonight at 7 p.m. at the Township Hall, 6582 Byron Rd. Bosma and township legal counsel Dave Eberle are expected to give a presentation on where things stand with the project.
Township residents and business owners are invited to the meeting. The township is asking anyone interested in attending to RSVP in advance so they can plan for adequate seating. A micro website dedicated specifically to Silver Maple has been set up where people can RSVP as well as submit questions to be answered during the meeting. That website is zeelandtwpvoice.org.
The township recently hired Holland-based communications firm Boileau & Co. to set up the micro website.
––––––––––––––––––––
Subscribe to the Legal News!
https://legalnews.com/Home/Subscription
Full access to public notices, articles, columns, archives, statistics, calendar and more
Day Pass Only $4.95!
One-County $80/year
Three-County & Full Pass also available




