How El-Sayed, Benson Won Michigan: Big Turnout, Democratic Shifts

Jocelyn Benson, left, and Abdul El-Sayed, won Michigan elections for governor and U.S. Senate on Nov. 3. 

(Ed. Note: This story was originally published by Bridge Michigan, a nonprofit and nonpartisan news organization. Visit the newsroom online: bridgemi.com.)

By Matt Mencarini

Bridge Michigan


Democrats Abdul El-Sayed and Jocelyn Benson rode a “blue wave” Nov. 3 to win Michigan’s U.S. Senate and governor’s races, respectively, outperforming recent party performance in an election that was a rebuke of President Donald Trump. 

Benson will succeed outgoing Gov. Gretchen Whitmer after beating Republican John James by more than 10 percentage points. 

El-Sayed, a progressive who campaigned on universal healthcare and taxing the rich, defeated Republican Mike Rogers by about seven points, defending the seat to help Democrats retake control of the U.S. Senate. 

Here’s a look at how they secured victory:

High turnout, broad Democratic shifts

El-Sayed and Benson both benefited from relatively high turnout across the state, particularly among Democratic voters. 

More than 4.8 million voters cast ballots in Michigan. That appears to be a midterm record, topping the 4.5 million Michiganders who voted in 2022 but shy of the 5.7 million who cast ballots in the 2024 presidential election that Trump won. 

Benson won 18 counties, while El-Sayed won 14, including several of the most populous counties that helped make up for losses in more rural areas. 

But even in the counties they lost, Benson and El-Sayed exceeded expectations. 

All 83 Michigan counties shifted toward Democrats compared with the 2024 election, according to an analysis by the Associated Press. That included a 14-percentage point shift in Wayne County, the state’s largest, but also double-digit shifts in more rural areas like Dickinson, Branch and St. Joseph counties.

In Wexford County, where Rogers won by a smaller margin than two years ago, retired Manton voter Jerrilyn Mathews, a former Republican, said she voted for El-Sayed, other Democrats and “anything against Trump.” 

—————

Detroit and Wayne County

El-Sayed and Benson each got more than 70% of the vote in their respective races. Both outperformed 2024 Democratic presidential nominee Kamala Harris, who topped Trump with 63% of the Wayne County vote in 2024. 

In Detroit, the state’s largest city, Benson won about 93% of the vote and El-Sayed won about 92%, according to unofficial results. Both topped the 90% Harris won in Detroit two years ago. 

Rogers spent considerable time in Detroit and touted inroads with Democrats, including outgoing state Rep. Karen Whitsett. But he received only 5% of the city vote in Tuesday’s election, down from the 7% he won there in his 2024 loss to U.S. Sen. Elissa Slotkin. 

“I voted to go against Trump. When it all comes down to it, we are trying to vote against Trump,” said Henry McCoi of Detroit, who cast his ballot at Mayberry Elementary School.

—————

Oakland County

Rogers also heavily courted Jewish voters turned off by El-Sayed’s opposition to U.S. support for Israel and comments in the wake of a March attack on Temple Israel in West Bloomfield Township. 

Unofficial results show Rogers did improve his vote share in some Oakland County communities with heavy Jewish populations, but he did not gain enough ground to make up for Democratic shifts in other parts of the county and state.

In West Bloomfield Township, for instance, Rogers won 46% of the vote, up from 42% in 2024. El-Sayed won the township by 2,240 votes, down from the 5,538-vote margin Slotkin won it by two years ago.

All told, El-Sayed won Oakland County with 56% of the vote, topping Harris’ 54% in 2024. 

In Huntington Woods, which El-Sayed carried, 55-year-old Lauren Slutsky described herself as a lifelong Jewish Democrat but said she voted for Rogers because El-Sayed “hasn’t proven that he will stand against antisemitism and hate.”

At the same polling place, Steve Gold stood wearing a “Jews for Abdul” shirt and praised El-Sayed’s push for Medicare for All, calling it “shameful that the United States has not provided healthcare to everybody after 250 years.”

Meanwhile, some metro Detroit communities with larger Muslim populations that had broken for Trump two years ago shifted back to Democrats Nov. 3. 

Trump won Dearborn by six percentage points in 2024, but El-Sayed won the city by 65 points on Tuesday, and Benson won it by 60 points, according to unofficial results. Dearborn Mayor Abdullah Hammoud said the city’s 45,464-voter turnout was the highest ever.

—————

College towns 

College towns also helped secure victories for El-Sayed and Benson. 

In Washtenaw County, El-Sayed won there with 74% of the vote. Benson received about 75%. Both outperformed Harris, who had won 71% of Washtenaw County votes in 2024.

El-Sayed and Benson also outperformed Harris in Ingham, Kalamazoo, Isabella and Kent counties, all home to universities and large groups of young voters.

Jack Morean, a 19-year-old Michigan State University student from Grand Rapids, voted in his first general election Tuesday morning at an on-campus precinct in East Lansing.

Morean said he voted for Democrats up and down his ballot. 

“We’re in a time where divisiveness is very apparent,” he said. “Our current government is honestly abhorrent. I’m here to vote for change.”

Matt Mencarini is a Report for America corps member who covers data and accountability for Bridge Michigan.


NNA Joins News/Media Alliance to Push Back Against OpenAI


Federal courts must build a firewall between artificial intelligence programs and local news organizations, said National Newspaper Association Chair Jeremy Gulban, chief executive officer of CherryRoad Media of Parsippany, N.J.

NNA on Nov. 1 joined an amicus brief filed by News/Media Alliance on behalf of local news organizations in the federal Southern District of New York, where multiple newspapers are suing to block Open AI from taking local news content for free.

The National Newspaper Association is a 141-year-old organization representing local community newspapers. It represents members in every state. Its members publish in print and in all digital formats, including websites, mobile applications, and commercial platforms. Its typical member is a 3,000 to 5,000 circulation nondaily newspaper with staff based in communities they serve.

“Huge AI enterprises like OpenAI cannot be allowed to hide behind the fair use doctrine or any other legal defense,” Gulban said. “If the courts allow them to do so, the first loss will be to local news reporting.”

The New York case is in a summary judgment phase, where the court is urged to resolve key legal issues about copyright infringement and fair use.

Gulban said the AI programs threaten the jobs of local reporters and editors and are likely to deprive local communities of reporters on the scene to cover city governments, civic affairs, youth sports and the activities of churches and nonprofit groups.

“OpenAI and its colleagues in the AI space should not be able to lift local journalism content, neither for training, nor remarketing, nor for any other purpose," Gulban said. “Publishers depend upon copyright laws to protect the work of journalists, as well as the messages of many local businesses that count on our publications to promote their products and services.”

News/Media Alliance, the National Press Photographers Association and ProPublica were signatories on the brief. Gulban said he appreciated the work of N/MA to express the industry’s views.

Gulban also said community newspapers had a growing concern about all types of digital producers that see newspaper content as a free service, available for their own use to repackage and sell for profit.

“We’ve had enough,” he said. “It’s time for public policy to shore up traditional protections for copyrights.”


Consumers Provides Regulators More Time to Approve Dam Sales


Consumers Energy has provided state regulators additional time to approve the sale of the company’s 13 hydroelectric dams to Confluence Hydro as it continues to work toward an outcome to keep the dams in place.

Consumers Energy is providing the Michigan Public Service Commission more time to allow the Company to continue working with interested parties to achieve a constructive settlement. The extension moves the deadline for the Commission’s decision on the sale from Nov. 9 to Dec. 17.

“We understand the desire for communities and our coworkers for an outcome in this case. We are providing for a little more time to reach a constructive agreement that will be a win for our customers, Michigan, and the communities we care about,” said Chris Fultz, Consumers Energy’s senior vice president of electric supply.

“We continue to work with others to find solutions to ensure these dams will continue to operate safely and responsibly for years to come. We recognize some parties have publicly opposed continuing settlement efforts. Consumers Energy respectfully disagrees and remains committed to working in good faith to achieve a constructive settlement for the benefit of customers, communities and the State of Michigan.”

Consumers Energy last year submitted an agreement to sell the dams on five rivers to Confluence Hydro and buy the energy they generate. That provides an incentive to keep all 13 dams in place for at least 30 years and save Consumers Energy customers around $500 million compared to decommissioning the dams.


Mackinac Center Sues Over Proposal 2


By Jamie A. Hope 

Michigan Capitol Confidential


The Mackinac Center for Public Policy filed a lawsuit Nov. 3 against Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson and Attorney General Dana Nessel after Michiganders approved Proposal 2 by a vote of 81.2% to 18.8%. 

Prop 2, the research and educational institute said, curbs free speech and is thus unconstitutional.

The lawsuit, filed in U.S. District Court for the Western District of Michigan, Southern Division, challenges Prop 2’s campaign finance provisions included in the proposal. Those provisions, it said, will hinder free speech and the financial anonymity of nonprofits, journalists and residents.

The Mackinac Center asked the court to declare two provisions in the proposal unconstitutional and block its enforcement.

The Mackinac Center is represented by the Institute of Free Speech.

Prop 2 regulates speech when an individual or organization speaks on a candidate or ballot question, regardless of whether they advocate a vote, the Mackinac Center said in a press release issued Nov. 3.

Prop 2 will turn free, educational, and neutral speech into campaign speech that requires oversight, the Mackinac Center said. It adds that the new law will require organizations, media centers, and others to disclose the names, addresses, occupations, and employers of their financial donors, subscribers, members and other financial supporters.

Prop 2 would apply to neutral news reporting, social media posts, and research, the Mackinac Center said.

It is a Trojan Horse, Mackinac Center Executive Vice President Michael Reitz wrote in a Detroit News op-ed. If a church welcomes a candidate to Sunday service or a PTA posts about a school millage it could be in need of a campaign finance lawyer, Reitz said.

Michiganders shouldn’t face disclosure requirements or risk fines or jail because they discuss politicians, policy or elections, Patrick J. Wright, director of the Mackinac Center Legal Foundation told Michigan Capitol Confidential in an email.

Prop 2’s new disclosure requirements apply to any person or organization, including media organizations, that spends more than $5,000 in a year on communications that reference candidates within 30 days of a primary and 100 days of a general election.

Attorneys for the plaintiff say that political speech has strong constitutional protections.

“The First Amendment guarantees people the freedom to praise and criticize the elected officials who govern us,” said Brett Nolan, senior attorney at the Institute for Free Speech and lead litigator on the case, in the press release.

Michigan Capitol Confidential is the news source produced by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Michigan Capitol Confidential reports with a free-market news perspective.